Home>News Center>Life | ||
Diana photographers confirmed acquittal
A French appeals court acquitted three photographers of charges they broke privacy laws by photographing Diana, Princess of Wales the night of her fatal accident in Paris in 1997.
"The judges showed courage," said Langevin, the only one of the three defendants present at the hearing in the Paris appeals court.
Chassery's attorney Jean-Louis Pelletier called the verdict "very important" for the defense of freedom of the press.
The judgement was a defeat for Mohamed Al-Fayed, the millionaire Egyptian father of Diana's companion Dodi, and for the French state prosecutor's office, both of which had argued that the vehicle constituted a private space protected from the photographers' cameras.
Al-Fayed's lawyer Fabrice Dubest said he would take the case to the Cour de Cassation, France's highest appeals court.
Diana, 36, and Dodi Fayed, 42, died on the night of August 31, 1997, shortly after leaving the Ritz Hotel owned by Al-Fayed. Their chauffeur, Henri Paul, who also died, was found in the official French inquest to have been responsible for the crash because he was driving drunk at high speed.
The main investigation on the causes of the accident was closed in April 2002, putting an end to formal manslaughter inquiries brought against nine photographers -- including the three judged Tuesday -- and a press motorcyclist.
But Al-Fayed, angry that Chassery, Langevin and Martinez had taken photos of Diana and Dodi as they left the Ritz and then as the couple lay in the wreckage of the crashed Mercedes, lodged the appeal on the privacy issue.
Langevin took two photos at the Ritz, Chassery took one at the hotel and one after the accident, and Martinez snapped two photos after the crash in a tunnel near the Seine.
The state prosecutor's office offered mild support for the appeal, but only for the photos taken at the Ritz. At a June hearing in the appeal case, its lawyers asked that the photographers be acquitted for the pictures taken at the scene of the accident on grounds of press freedom.
Chassery, a freelance photographer at the time, Langevin, who worked for the Sygma/Corbis agency, and Martinez of the Angeli agency were originally acquitted when a lower court determined they did not photograph any intimate moments and that the inside of a car did not constitute a private place.
On Tuesday, the court ruled that the three had not captured any gestures on film at the Ritz that revealed aspects of Diana and Dodi's private life. It said the couple's car could not be considered a private place after the crash.
An investigation is still under way in Paris on the validity of toxicology tests conducted on Paul after the crash.
Paul's parents contend that the samples used to conclude that their son was responsible for the deaths did not come from Paul's body.
Britain's top police official, John Stevens, is also conducting an inquiry to determine whether Al-Fayed's claims that the crash was not an accident have any basis in truth.
Al-Fayed has insisted the death was the work of British intelligence services worried about Diana's relationship with his son.
|
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||